Can Artificial Intelligence Understand Goodness? An Abrahamic Perspective
Can Artificial Intelligence Understand Goodness? An Abrahamic Perspective
Publish Date: 2026-07-13 05:21:00
Source Domain: countercurrents.org
Here’s a summary of David S. Soriano’s “Illustration of Artificial General Intelligence” with key points presented as an unordered list:
-
Distinguishing Intelligence from Understanding:
- AI can perform tasks at a level that mirrors or even surpasses humans in certain areas.
- However, it lacks true “understanding” which involves reflecting morally and ethically on the nature of “good”.
- Intelligence and understanding are not the same, with machines lacking the ethical discernment and reflectiveness of human conscience.
-
The Abrahamic Traditions and Ethics:
- Abrahamic religions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) and secular humanist perspectives agree that true moral discernment belongs uniquely to humans.
- “Goodness” is based on reflective, conscience-driven understanding not replicable by AI.
-
The Human Capacity for Moral Agency:
- Humans possess an intrinsic moral capacity rooted in their relationship with the Divine.
- This capacity is marked by free will, conscience, and the ability to act freely toward the good.
-
Concerns About AI Governance:
- AI could be easily repurposed for surveillance and oppression.
- AI lacks moral agency and conscience, thus cannot inherently ensure just and ethical outcomes. Humans must ensure AI serves human dignity.
-
Public Participation and Ethical Standards:
- Broad public inclusion is essential, but must be supplemented with ethical standards.
- Majority consensus does not inherently equate to moral correctness.
- Moral standards must guide the development and deployment of AI.
-
Dignity as the Central Ethical Standard:
- Human dignity, encompassing inherent, non-negotiable respect for human beings, must guide AI ethics.
- Dignity requires that no algorithmic decision-making can reduce persons to mere data points or utilitarian calculations.
-
Final Reflection on Wisdom and AI:
- Wisdom, which requires reflection and ethical grounding, cannot be inferred from data processing or computational outputs.
- Ethical and theological reflection is crucial to ensuring AI aligns with the concept of good, avoiding AI redefining and potentially undermining that concept.
Thus, Soriano argues sophisticated AI retains its limitations in moral understanding and emphasizes the indispensable role of human ethical discernment in its governance and application.
